← Back to Insights

CRM & Email Marketing · Q&A

How often should we email customers?

Kate Barrett Draft · 5 min read

There isn't a safe weekly number, and anyone who gives you one is guessing on your behalf. The right frequency is whatever your list/segment's own behaviour will tolerate before relevance runs out, and that tolerance is likely different for every list, every season and every customer stage.

Your team already knows this instinctively, which is why the “how many emails a week” question keeps getting asked even after someone answers it. That repetition is nerves talking, dressed up as a question about a number (the number is the easy part to hide behind).

Your list is already telling you the answer

Most CRM teams have more evidence sitting in their own platform than they think.

Open a segment's engagement history and if send frequency has increaed, you'll usually see a point where clicks flatten even as sends keep climbing. That point is your actual ceiling - already logged, just never looked at. When did anyone on your team last go and check?

The benchmark habit

The instinct is to reach for an industry benchmark instead (whatever a webinar slide or a vendor blog said last quarter): “ecommerce sends three a week,” “SaaS sends one.”

Benchmarks describe someone else's list, built on someone else's trust, at a different point in that relationship. Applying one to your own segment is like borrowing a stranger's diet plan because you're roughly the same height - would you actually trust that plan to work?

A pattern worth naming here: in a recent email marketing audit, a client's most-engaged segment had a lower click rate at four emails a week than a nearly identical segment on a competitor's account got at one.
The difference wasn't frequency. It was that the higher-volume list had earned it, message by message, over eighteen months.

What frequency actually measures

Frequency isn't really the variable you're testing. It's a stand-in for the expectations you set on sign up and the relevance you deliver, and it behaves differently depending on how much trust, relevance and value you've already banked with that segment.

A segment that trusts you can absorb more volume without complaint.

A segment you've been sending blanket promotions to for a year can't absorb a second weekly email, because you never built the credit you're now trying to spend.

This is relevance beating volume in practice: it works every time, and volume only ever works when relevance is already doing the heavy lifting underneath it.

What's actually happening when a customer stops opening

Your subscriber doesn't consciously decide “that's one email too many” (almost nobody thinks in those terms). They just stop paying full attention, and the drop happens well before they unsubscribe.

The attention tax

Every email you send costs your reader something, even the ones they never open. It costs a fraction of a second of scanning, a tiny judgement about whether you're worth the click today, repeated every single time you land in the inbox.

Send with the right relevance and that cost feels worth paying. Send without it and the cost starts to outweigh what you're offering, and your reader's brain quietly reclassifies you: from sender worth checking to sender I scroll past.

That reclassification is where your end-point deliverability actually breaks, long before your open rate tells you anything. Deliverability and engagement isn't just a technical problem: it's downstream of what your sending pattern has taught the reader to expect from you.

Why the damage is invisible for months

Mailbox providers watch this shift too, and they often act on it faster than your reporting does.

A list that's quietly stopped paying attention to you gets deprioritised at the provider level before your metrics show a single sign of trouble (Gmail and Outlook are both doing this constantly, on your behalf, without telling you). By the time your open numbers move, the real damage happened weeks earlier.

NOTE: Open rate is genuinely unreliable evidence in email reporting (inflated by image pre-fetching and privacy proxies), and it tells you almost nothing about whether your frequency is working. Watch what happens after the click instead: does engagement hold steady as volume rises, or does it bend?

The commercial cost of getting this wrong

Get frequency wrong in either direction and it shows up on the P&L, not just in a dashboard nobody checks. What does a single over-mailed segment actually cost you by the end of the quarter?

Send too rarely to a segment that could handle more, and you're leaving revenue on the table every week that segment sits idle between messages.

Send too often to a segment that can't absorb it, and you're paying to reach people who've already left and potentially increasing list churn.

The number that matters here: acquiring a replacement for a subscriber your own frequency drove away costs several times more than keeping the one you had. Every list you've over-mailed into disengagement widens the retention gap a little further, and it's a small, repeating acquisition bill you didn't need to write.

The decision

If this were my programme, I wouldn't set a frequency target at all - I'd set a relevance threshold per segment, and let frequency follow it rather than lead it.

That means testing upward from wherever you sit today, one added send at a time, and watching engagement rather than assuming a ceiling exists until your own data proves one. It also means testing downward on any segment where engagement's already thin, because sending less to a struggling list is usually the fix nobody wants to try first (it feels like giving up ground, so it rarely gets proposed in a planning meeting).

Would your team actually propose sending less, in a room full of people whose targets go up every quarter?

  • Review: pull engagement trend by segment over the last 90 days and mark exactly where clicks flatten while sends keep rising.
  • Decide: set a working frequency ceiling per segment, based on that flattening point, rather than a single company-wide number.
  • Test: move one segment up by one send and one segment down by one send for a full cycle, then compare engagement and revenue per send, not sends in isolation.

Where this actually leaves you

Your reader isn't counting emails. They're noticing, send after send, whether opening you keeps paying off.

That's the only number worth optimising for, and it isn't visible in a benchmark (however confidently the benchmark is presented). It's sitting in your own segment data, waiting for someone to actually go and look at it.

Before you plan anything else, check where you actually are

If you want to know which of your six CRM capabilities to fix first, our free CRM Priority Check will tell you.

Eleven questions, about five minutes, and you leave with your CRM Priority Score, the one capability that’s quietly capping the other five, and a first step for it that fits inside a normal week.

It scores what your team actually does today rather than what’s planned, so treat the result as a useful and slightly optimistic place to start: https://kate-offnr2k6.scoreapp.com/

Discover your CRM Priority >

Keep the ideas coming

CRM Spotlight,
straight to your inbox.

Monthly tips, insights, offers and free resources for your CRM and email marketing.

Sign up to CRM Spotlight ↗

You can unsubscribe at any time.

Put the thinking into practice

Where should you
focus next?

Take the free CRM Priority Quiz for an initial view of your CRM capability and where further attention may be useful.

Take your free CRM & Email Priority Quiz ↗

About the author

Kate Barrett

Founder and director of eFocus Marketing, CRM strategist and bestselling author, with over eighteen years’ experience in CRM and email marketing.

Meet Kate Barrett ↗

Ready to take your email marketing to the next level?

If you want help to create a customer-centric, personalised, intelligent email marketing programme, get in touch with eFocus Marketing and discover how we can help you skyrocket your results.

eFocus Marketing logo

Free Peak Readiness Assessment

Is your CRM ready for Black Friday?

Answer 22 questions to get your readiness score, your sharpest gap with three actions to take this week, and a to-do list for before, during and after the peak.

Start my free assessment

Free. A few minutes. Black Friday is on 27 November 2026, so the sooner you know, the more you can fix.